Pixel 4 Case vs. Catalyst Impact Case

Hey folks, trying something new out with how I've redone my little office area.

Reviewing these 2 cases, the Pixel 4 Case from Google and the Catalyst Impact case for the Pixel 4.

#MadeByGoogle is $50CDN
Catalyst is $60CDN ($40USD)

Both are fairly sturdy, have good connection with the buttons and have that lip to protect the screen when it's face down.  The Catalyst has more 'drop protection' saying it's good for 9.9'.  I wasn't about to test that.

What do you look for in your phone's case?